“A man’s life is interesting primarily when he has failed — I well know. For it’s a sign that he tried to surpass himself.”
– Georges Clemenceau
Yesterday, a friend pointed me to Brené Brown’s Perfect Protest. All this protesting of perfection got me thinking about the difference between doing your best and needing to be perfect. Apparently Georges Clemenceau, French Prime Minister during World War I, was thinking about these things long before I was born; so I have to assume that this is the sort of struggle that people have faced as long as there have been people.
I won’t lie to you. I’ve always envied people whose clothes not only match, but they actually coordinate in a way that looks “put together.” I’ve always marveled at magazine-worthy homes with little knick knacks and stunning artwork and lush white carpet that, without any words spoken, reminds you to leave your shoes by the door. As I enter my 41st year of actively parenting my wild brood, I look back on times when I snagged the still-wearable polo shirt of one of my sons from the Goodwill bag and made it my take-the-little-ones-to-the-playground garb. I think of all the damage that flying frisbees and bouncing basketballs could have done to stunning artwork; and I revel in the realization I had after a rainy afternoon sent a horde of boys running for refuge in our house, that any new carpet I would choose should be the color of the dirt in my backyard when it is dry. Then the muddy footprints would be less distracting.
I think of the Christmas when my mother’s gift to me was an Organizer Handbag — a marvelous invention with a place for everything and, theoretically, everything in its place. Well, the organizer folks didn’t account for a compartment to carry a batting glove or a slightly-damp baseball. The cell phone pouch actually worked pretty well for the hair elastics, neosporin, and bandaids that were necessary for summer trips to the outdoor basketball league. My mother called me just after New Year’s Day:
“How do you like your new purse?’
“It’s great,” I answered, “but those little keyrings with the snaps keep getting lost in the bottom of the bag.”
“You’re supposed to snap them in.”
“I know, Mom…give it up.”
My mother has always been practically perfect in every way. She was valedictorian of every study she ever pursued. She has always been impeccably groomed and dressed. She has lived life by the rules, and it has worked well for her. Measuring her value by her achievements probably made up for the feeling of being “less” that grew out of being a child of divorce in the 1930’s in a rather unforgiving small town. We have made it a point, as adults, to hug our mom in more than a perfunctory way — until she could feel that she deserved the warmth. She will forever know the exact count of the push pins in the little box in her desk — second drawer down, left side, under the paper clips; and I will envy that as I rummage for the stapler because I can’t find a clip. Mom has dementia now, and some of her perfection filters have been lost in the changes to her brain. I’m kind of liking this unfiltered version of my mother — she has an air of freedom and happiness that no longer need to be organized and analyzed in order to be appreciated.
I hope that Clemenceau is right. I hope that it is in having the courage to step beyond our known limits and experience failure that our lives become interesting. I hope that the day never comes when I feel that I have “arrived,” and that I no longer need to step beyond the limits of today and strive to grow tomorrow. Thomas Edison said that he hadn’t failed — he had discovered 10,000 ways that didn’t work. How’s that for reaching beyond limitations and toward the unknown? And how is Thomas Edison as an example of someone whose life was full and interesting?
So here’s to five extra teenagers showing up for dinner with my son, and two homemade pizzas thrown in the oven at the last minute as a complement to the roasted chicken with potatoes and gravy. I’m sure the meal would have failed the planning test in Home Economics, but I like to think that it cooked up some memories for the guys who experienced its unique ambience. Here’s to popcorn in the sofa cushions and every blanket and pillow in the house making a nest for the kids to watch a movie. There are few messes that can’t be cleaned up; and I think that’s a good way to see our own less-than-perfect outcomes as we tentatively step over the boundaries that contain us and find new adventures that allow us to live life to the fullest. Here’s to the perfect fingerprints that have graced my windows and the perfect mud that has been tracked through my house. When the day comes that the path stays clean, I’m sure I will miss it. Maybe then I will get a knick knack or two.
And I’m betting that my kids will have white carpets.